Meal Planning Without a Menu
- by keeping the kitchen stocked with basics.
One piece of advice you will probably see on most frugal homemaking blogs is to plan your meals for the week before you go to the grocery store. I understand the logic; by planning you buy only what you need for a week, and are sure you have the ingredients for the meals you will be making. Another benefit of planning meals is that you don't have to figure out what is for dinner at 4:00 when the kids are driving you crazy, and the last thing you want to do is think. It makes sense.
I don't do it. I used to early in our marriage. I would sit down with my cookbook and look at recipes, plan the meals, make the list and go to the store. The problem was the meals that looked so good in the cookbook usually included high end meats, seafood or special ingredients. I was not utilizing sale items. We were eating well, but not exactly frugally.
The next step in menu planning for me was to sit down with the ads first and plan meals and lists using the sale items. That helped, and I got pretty good at using coupons and loss leaders. We were still eating well, but now a bit more frugally.
Then fast forward a few years and a few kids later, I had gotten out of the habit of planning our meals. Matching up coupons, sales ads, and menus was taking too much time. I found that I could feed us just as well, often for less money, by shopping at low cost grocery stores and keeping a consistent stock of frugal basics in my cupboard and basics in my refrigerator Other items were only picked up only when I saw them marked down or there was a fantastic sale. I learned to cook a variety of meals using basic and cheap items. Still eating well and frugally, but investing a lot less time.
Those two linked lists above certainly don't cover all the staples in the house, but they do give you a good idea of what is there. You'll also find last year's garden produce in the pantry. In the freezer you'll find the meat. Much of our meat now comes from our homestead, but when I bought all our meat it was the basics. I rarely would pay more than $2.00 a pound for meat, and generally would create most meals from hamburger and whole chickens, or other meats on sale.
Lest, you think meals would be boring by using the "keep your kitchen stocked with the basics" method I use, let me assure you they are not. There is not a lot of repetition in our meals. A huge amount of different meals can be made from using the same basic ingredients. Using the same foods in different combinations helps to mix it up a bit too. Even my fall back meals, like quesadillas or pizza can be made with enough variety to keep it interesting even if we did just eat them last week.
For example quesadillas can be made with just cheese, cheese and onion, cheese and leftover chili, beans, meat, green pepper, or whatever you have on hand. They can be served with beans, rice, fresh salsa, guacamole, black bean salsa, or soup. I think I could serve these three times a week without anyone complaining.
Meal planning can work, but it does take time. It can help you stay in a budget when done carefully, and it can save your sanity on those crazy days, but it isn't the only way. I don't plan my meals for the week. My sanity saver is those fall back meals that are simple and quick. The ingredients for those meals can always be found in my kitchen. Keeping in the budget is simple because I buy the same basics consistently, and supplement with marked down items noticed while shopping. Keeping the kitchen stocked with the basics is the way I plan for our meals. It is frugal meal planning without the time investment of menu planning with ads and coupons.








9 comments:
Hmmm, I kind of combine the two. For the most part I shop for the pantry, and then I make up my meal plan based on what is already in the fridge that I need to use up, and what I have on hand. So I buy meat etc when it is on sale (but not that much anymore, I've got a freezer full of venison-it's silly to buy ground beef!-but I did stock up on pork when the entire loins were on sale for $1.49 lb. Had them cut into chops and roasts), and only very, very occasionally buy something specifically for a recipe.
For the last month or so I've been trying to add fish into our diet at least once a week. Then I'll start making sure I have a pasta dish (light on meat-cheaper that way) and once I've got those two down, I'll start ensuring that I have one vegetarian/legume meal.
Works for me :)
Stephanie,
I really appreciated this post. Amy (The Motherload) did a recent post on stockpiling meal planning and I'm so interested in the idea.
At what point do you decide what you'll make for dinner that night? I always feel so haphazard planning day to day, but maybe I just need to relax and let it work for me!
Early in our marriage, I used the loss leaders (which are usually meats) to determine what else I bought. If chuck roasts or stew meat were on sale, I'd plan to make stew or stroganoff and buy the rest of the ingredients. When I got home, I'd list the meals I had the ingredients for on a dry erase board on the fridge. I couold easily glance at the board in the morning or the night before and know what I was going to make.
Now, I am much more like you. I stockpile basics like canned veggies, noodles, rice, etc. when they are on sale. My freezer is regularly stocked with meats that I use for several kinds of meals. Great post!
Jenn,
We do a lot of no meat meals too. I try to incorporate fish, but it is so darn expensive! Maybe one of the kids' will take up fishing as a hobby!
Carrie,
Well there is not set answer for that. I usually pull out several things from the freezer to thaw for the week. I decide what to make sometime in the afternoon. On a busy day I like to get something in the crockpot in the morning, but that doesn't always happen, like last night. It was 6:30 before I was ready to cook, and really wasn't sure what we were having. I fell back on eggs, toast and fried potatoes.
Planning isn't necessarily bad. It really works for some. If you want to spend less time though maybe a good compromise would be to make a list of things you're family likes well and whose ingredients can be staples in the kitchen. Keep those ingredients stocked then you can refer to that list to decide what to have instead of creating anew list every week. Of course then you can add different items when you get a craving for something or there is a really good sale.
Hope that helps.
Steph-Well, I am lucky to have a BIL who loves to fish, but doesn't like eating it! We also have friends who catch a ridiculous amt of salmon every year. But even so I have been buying some frozen filets at Aldi's. Also I'm trying to use canned fish like canned salmon and tuna. Personally I love Salmon loaf or Salmon patties (fried-the only way to go) and either of those can be 1/2 canned salmon and 1/2 tunafish, or even all tunafish.
Jenn,
Fishermen and hunters! You are a lucky gal!
I forgot about canned fish. That is part of our normal stocked items too. Salmon patties are wonderful! We probably have them about once a month and tuna salad a couple time a month.
You're incredible. Considering the apple doesn't fall far from the tree, I suppose your mom is still married? *grin*
Thanks for participating in this week’s
Carnival of Family Life hosted by Pickel at My Two Boys. The Carnival will be live on Monday, April 7, 2008, so make sure you stop by and check out all of the other outstanding entries included in this week’s Edition!
Good post
I'm too "creative" to buy for a menu. I "plan" around what I have and what mood I'm in. And I don't follow recipes.
Post a Comment